You are now on Legacy.com. Your site use is governed by their Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy. Any purchases are with Legacy.com. Learn More

Search by Name

Search by Name

James KNATCHBULL-HUGESSEN Obituary

Jim died peacefully, on April 21, 2024, in Almonte, Ontario, at the age of 90, with his wife, Louise, and family at his side. Born in Montreal in 1933, Jim was educated at Bishop's College School, Oxford and McGill. After graduating with a B.C.L. from McGill in 1957 and studying for the bar at the Université de Montréal, he entered private practice at his family's firm, now known as McCarthy Tetrault. From 1962 to 1974, he was an adjunct professor at McGill's Faculty of Law. In 1972, he was appointed Justice and later Associate Chief Justice of the Quebec Superior Court. . In 1983, he was appointed to the Federal Court of Appeal of Canada, later moving to the trial division. When he lost his eyesight in the 1990s, he served as the chair of the federal Task Force on Access to Information for Print-Disabled Canadians, later establishing a fellowship in disability law at McGill University. Following his retirement in 2008, he received the F.R. Scott Award for Distinguished Service, recognizing his outstanding career and service to McGill's Faculty of Law. In 2014, he was named a Member of the Order of Canada for his contribution to the advancement of disability law. Other appointments included the vice-presidency of the International Labour Organization's Administrative Tribunal and the Supreme Court of the North-West Territories. During his Oxford days, Jim rowed for Balliol College, winning many a regatta with his eight. He was an avid sailor, accomplished skier (yes, as a blind man!), keen fisherman, and horseback rider (his horse, Kahlua, was also blind, in one eye). Jim was a talented performer, receiving rave reviews as the male lead in McGill's acclaimed musical, My Fur Lady, and later appearing in several Almonte productions for the local theatre troupe, Sage Age. He was famous among family and friends for his tendency to burst into song or recite poetry to punctuate whatever topic was being discussed. Jim balanced his career with a rich family life, in addition to pursuing his love of sports and many other interests. His commitment to family was unparalleled and his devotion to his first wife, Mary, their children, his nieces (two of whom lived with the family for several years after their parents' deaths), nephews, and various dogs and cats, made for a close-knit Hugessen clan. He loved sharing his passions with his children, who have fond memories of their many adventures in New Brunswick and the Laurentians. The Hugessen dinner table (Jim presiding!), was always a favourite gathering place, where debates, witty banter and relentless teasing were rife, and having the last word on any subject was a major accomplishment. Jim will be lovingly remembered by Louise; his children, Jaime (Elizabeth), Jill (Marc), Lys (Dajan), Alex (Samantha) and Ross (Kathryn); and his grandchildren, Henri (Rocio), James, Richard, Megan, Claire, Matthew, Jeffrey, Michael, Kai, Jake, Naomi and Ben. Jim was predeceased by his wife of 50 years, Mary; his siblings, Ted, Kenneth, Andrew and Mary; and his grandson, Justin (1993-2009). It is a fortunate man who has the opportunity to experience great love for a second time. For the past 10 years, Jim's second wife, Louise Stevenson, has given him this precious gift and remained steadfast at his side. Their marriage was filled with laughter, banter, travel and friends, and Jim embraced her family, Imre (Lesley), Elizabeth, Eric, Alden, Olivia (Taylor), Jillian (Sam) and Griffin, as his own. Family and close friends will celebrate Jim's life with a small service at St. Paul's Church, Almonte, on May 11, 2024. In lieu of flowers, donations to the CNIB, one of Jim's favourite causes, would be appreciated.

To plant trees in memory, please visit the Sympathy Store.

Published by The Globe and Mail from Apr. 24 to Apr. 28, 2024.

Memories and Condolences
for James KNATCHBULL-HUGESSEN

Not sure what to say?





28 Entries

Single Memorial Tree

Sylvie Laplante & Robert Sands

Planted Trees

Aidan O'Neill

April 30, 2024

I appeared before Justice Hugessen many years ago, at a time when he was doing mediations at the Federal Court level.

Notwithstanding his visual impairment, he had read all the submissions and put his finger on the crux of the dispute within about 30 seconds of calling the adversaries "to order".

This was hardly surprising as he had a richly deserved reputation among those of us who practised before the Federal Court as one of the "brainiest" judges we would ever encounter.

In my particular case, he was definitely a gentleman to deal with and I was very pleased to have finally appeared before him.

In part, this was because I had grown up with my late mother, Elizabeth Stevenson, referring to him as Cousin Jim, and telling me that her family used to visit the Hugessens on McTavish Street, above the McGill campus, and toboggan down the street -- or so she said.

After the mediation was over, I introduced myself to Cousin Jim, finally identifying my conflict of interest as one of his long lost "blood kin".

He laughed and asked me to give his best to my mother who, I understand, was his first cousin, once removed, as her father, Dr James Stevenson of Quebec City, was his father's "Uncle Jim".

Please accept my most sincere condolences for your family's loss.

It is very clear from the obituary and all the posted comments that he lived a very full and rich life and was beloved by many.

Aidan O'Neill

Sylvie Girard

April 29, 2024

My deepest sympathies Jill, to you and your family. May this moment of mourning bring together those who were dear to him

Stephen Scott

April 28, 2024

I join to offer condolences and memories of a mentor and a friend of nearly sixty years, who was both "My Lord",-- on the one occasion when I pleaded before him,-- and, through the years, mostly, Jim.

We first met in the classroom at the Law Faculty, in 1965-66, when, still in the practice of law, he taught our class, B.C.L. 1966, Civil Procedure. He taught crisply, clearly, succinctly and thoroughly. His was by far the best of my "Civ Pro" courses, and I think more broadly that there was no better lecturer in the Faculty. His air of authority had the respect of the class, and there was never any of the usual noise or nonsense when he was teaching. He was exacting in his grading, and my B+ grade was considered exceptional hy my peers.

He was, about 38 when appointed to the Superior Court, and promoted to become Associate Chief Justice a few years later, about age 41 or 42. Not long afterwards, one of his colleagues on the Superior Court bench remarked to me, "We used to call him "young Jim", but we´re not calling him that anymore."

In the years which followed, I used to send students to attend hearings in his Court to see trials run flawlessly and to learn from them.

We used to lunch periodically in Old Montreal near the Court House. One favorite of ours and of of the profession,was an excellent restaurant, Le Petit Havre (located in the former morgue!)

One day he sat down at the table and mentioned that, since one of his judges was ill, he had sat in "Divorce Court" that morning, and, before lunch, had divorced - I can´t now recall how many,-- perhaps ten or twenty couples, I responded "Those whom God hath joined !!" and he announced "I, James Hugessen, have put asunder!!_"

My remarkable experience in his Court was my acting as Counsel to the Crown in Re Ouellet (No. 1) (1976) reported at 67 D.L.R. (3d) 73 and elsewhere,-- the law reports do not record my appearance,,--the prosecution of the Minister of Consumer and Corporate Affairs, André Ouellet for contempt of court. I pleaded the parliamentary privilege issues, which Ouellet had raised in his defence. The whole affair was a saga with elements of farce. In connection with stablishing jurisdiction in Quebec, a surveyor established the location of the smoking lobby of the House of Commons in relation to the interprovincial boundary in the Ottawa River. We spoke of the case together in later years, and I should some day share my recollections. The judgment shows his consistently rigourous standards.

On another occasion, CBC As It Happens, with Barbara Frum, had me attend Court for a high profile judgment on a national issue. I phoned my report in to the programme live, from a pay-phone in the basement of the Court Gouse.

Through the years we enjoyed getting together periodically for dinner at BYOBs in Montreal, and this continued after his move to Ottawa, on occasions when he came to Montreal for Federal Court hearings,-- even after he began losing his vision.

He dealt with his affliction with courage, resolve and determination, and of course moved from the Federal Court of Appeal to the Trial Division to continue his service, since less reading was required on the trial bench.

Whether in terms of character, or of intellectual and professional rigour, I can think of no one whom I have through these many years held in higher regard than James Hugessen. His family´s loss will be widely shared.

The Board of Chez Doris

April 28, 2024

Jill,
The Board of Chez Doris wants to express our deepest condolences to you and your family. Our thoughts are with you.

Alan Diner

April 28, 2024

Some nice memories of Jim were captured in this piece by Bill Chapman of Almonte: https://open.substack.com/pub/lgwilliamchapman/p/james-knatchbull-hugessen-deceased?r=2b77un&utm_medium=ios

Howard Knopf

April 27, 2024

May his memory be a blessing. He was such a wonderful man and great judge who contributed, attended conferences, & excelled in so many ways even long after losing his eyesight but never his humanistic and juristic vision and dedication. I remember encountering him at a couple of conferences in New York which he got to on his own despite his eyesight loss and he graciously let me help him get around - though he was incredibly independent and did not really need help. He was a true inspiration. My sincere condolences to his family. Howard Knopf

Helen Mogford (Sentesy in the 1990's)

April 27, 2024

I got to know Mary and Jim through horses. I would ride with them in the 90's, on the third horse, Alibi. Jim's horse at that time was Just Foolin', I think. We had lovely times, and good conversations in the Almonte country side. I also house sit for them several times when Jim was away for the International Court sessions. Staying in his beautiful home on the river was a treat. Eventually, I was married to Barry in that very house, thanks to the generosity of both of them. When we returned from 2 years in Colombia, Jim gave me his old computer, and I still use the speaker system which has a good bass booster. I treasure lots of good memories of a kind, generous, wise man. My sympathies to the whole family.

Eric Thauvette

April 27, 2024

My sincere condolences to you and your family Jill

Annie Gagnon-Larocque

April 27, 2024

Dear Jill, my sincere sympathies. He lived a rich and full life, and will live on through you and all your family. Je pense à toi. Annie

Mary Larson

April 26, 2024

Dear Jill
Your father was clearly a wonderful man: truly larger than life and much loved. I send my condolences to you.
Warmly
Mary Larson

Carole Croteau

April 25, 2024

Jill my deepest condolences. Having such an inspiring man as a father is a tremendous chance. Felix Leclerc wrote: "C'est grand la mort, c'est plein de vie dedans". Your father really made the most of his.

Yves de Montigny, Chief Justice

April 25, 2024

On behalf of the members of the Federal Court of Appeal, please accept our warmest condolences. We are deeply sorry for your loss.

marshall rothstein

April 25, 2024

I appeared before Jim Hugessen as counsel when he was a judge of the Federal Court of Appeal. He was incisive and got to the central issue of the appeal immediately. He didn't like to waste time and it was sorry counsel who weren't properly prepared. His reputation was stellar. When I was appointed to the Federal Court Trial Division he was on the Federal Court of Appeal. When I went to the Federal Court of Appeal he went to the Trial Division. So I never got to sit with him. But I did benefit from become friends with him and Mary and enjoyed social occasions with them. Amongst the Canadian judiciary and legal profession he was highly respected. He was a truly great jurist.

Pierre Blais

April 25, 2024

Sincères condoléances, jim a été un collègue exceptionnel à la Cour Fédérale, j´ai beaucoup appris à ses côtés

Micheal Crane

April 25, 2024

I appeared before Justice Hugessen in 1998 in the Trial Division on an application for judicial review for a refugee case. I still remember him from that hearing. Court of Appeal justices would sometimes hear Trial Division cases in the summer. Having a Court of Appeal judge on the hearing made the hearing even more intimidating than usual. I recall that he was amused about something about the case or a submission that was made. He clearly enjoyed being a jurist. The reasons were delivered right after the hearing: short but elegant. He did not make a secret of having a visual disability, but had he not mentioned it during the hearing, you would not have known it.

robert décary

April 25, 2024

In addition to being a remarkable jurist, James was a wonderful colleague on the Federal Court of Appeal and a great travelling partner wherever we sat. Canada is loosing one of its brighest stars. I am loosing a very good friend.
He was so proud of his family. My condolances to all of you.

JENNIFER MERNER

April 25, 2024

My deepest sympathies to the whole family. Mr Hugessen was such a remarkable man, his kindness to me and my mom was extraordinary and will never be forgotten . RIP Judge Hugessen

Samantha Buckley-Hugessen

April 24, 2024

I have so many fun and fond memories of Jim. When I was new to the family, I was going to spend Christmas at Tremblant and wanted to bring a board game. "Trivial Pursuit! Yes, that will be fun" I was warned immediately by all of Jim's kids "He will destroy all of us at Trivial Pursuit, it won't be fun." Indeed he destroyed us in record time.
Jim was the wisest, most quick-witted man I have ever known. I was honoured to be welcomed into the family so warmly (especially, being a yank) in the early years of my moving to Canada, he reminded me, I was a yank! All in fun of course, and that is when I started calling him "Pops". So grateful to have known him and loved him. The best father-in-law ever. Rest in peace Pops.

Chapman B.A., LL.B. L. G. William

April 24, 2024

Dearest Louise and family, Please accept our heartfelt sympathies upon Jim's death. He was a fine man who led by example. L. G. William Chapman BA, LLB and Denis G. Arial, Almonte

Ron Ayling

April 24, 2024

A wonderful, talented man in so much - as well as being kind and gentle

Marc Nadon

April 24, 2024

I was a colleague of Jim on the federal court of appeal. I could write many pages to praise him but will simply say he was an exceptional man in every respect. He was highly respected by everyone. May he rest in peace.

Alan Diner

April 24, 2024

A wonderful mentor, articling principal, friend and raconteur, I remember Jim very fondly and vividly as a larger than life influence to everyone he touched. My wife and I were fortunate enough to celebrate Jim´s 90th birthday with him and Louise, and visit him on many occasions over the years.

Jim was a one-of-a-kind luminary to all of those who knew him - or simply read his judgments, which continue to be widely cited to this day. Jim overcame his challenges without ever complaining. Indeed, he could swim better, ski faster, and read more incisively than those perfectly sighted around him.

Jim embraced his former law clerks and their families as friends, and welcomed us into his home as if we were family. He treated us as equals. None of us will ever forget the amazing man that we were lucky enough to know, and always encouraged us as we went forward in our careers, with some of us even following in his footsteps.

My sincere condolences to Louise, Jamie, Jill, Lys, Alex and Ross.

Alan Diner

Paul Crampton, Chief Justice - Federal Court

April 24, 2024

Jim was held in great esteem, and with deep affection, by his colleagues at the Federal Court. He made a very substantial contribution to our jurisprudence and our processes. He will be widely missed. We extend our sincere condolences to his family.

Rimas Jon Gudelis

April 24, 2024

Fondest memory of The Judge giving son Jamie and me a good scolding for driving from Toronto to Mt. Tremblant when highway 401 was closed due to snowstorms. Discretely he understood the skiing would be great!

Anne & Mark Ireland

April 24, 2024

Sending our thoughts and prayers at this sad time.

Bill Bogart

April 24, 2024

I was the Director of Research for the Federal Court Rules Committee when Jim was Chair. He was astonishing. So smart, exacting, and a great sense of humour. Condolences to his family.

Francie Ducros

April 24, 2024

Dear Jill, our very, very sincere condolences. I remember your father so well as someone whom all looked up to, were inspired by, and learned from. What a legacy, the most important being his family and the love and kindness they always seem to show one another and those around them. Francie and Ian.

Showing 1 - 28 of 28 results

Memorial Events
for James KNATCHBULL-HUGESSEN

To offer your sympathy during this difficult time, you can now have memorial trees planted in a National Forest in memory of your loved one.