James Michael Carl

James Michael Carl

James Michael Carl, 91, passed away peacefully on August 12, 2025, after a short illness, surrounded by his family.

Born on June 4, 1934, in Oswego, New York, Jim was the youngest of nine children of Anna and Delos Miller Carl. He remained in his hometown through college, attending SUNY Oswego, where he was an active member of the Psi Phi fraternity.

Following his graduation, Jim served his country in the U.S. Army, stationed in Southeast Asia. After his service, he moved to Long Island, New York, where he began his teaching career and met the love of his life, Susan W. Hart. Jim went on to earn his master's degree and Doctorate of Education from Hofstra University. He dedicated more than 30 years to teaching in the Middle Country School District before retiring in 1988.

Jim's professional life extended beyond education. He was also a dedicated Realtor, continuing to help clients buy and sell homes well into his 90th year.

In retirement, Jim and Sue relocated to Wilmington, North Carolina, where he opened Lox, Stock, and Bagels, the city's first bagel shop. When he wasn't working, he enjoyed golfing and traveling the world. In 2010, they settled in Estero, Florida, where they have lived ever since.

Jim is survived by his beloved wife of 66 years, Susan; his five children, Pamela Routi (Mike), Karen Johnson (Corby), Kevin Carl, Elizabeth Egan (James), and James P. Carl; his six grandchildren, Callie Richardson, Ted Routi, Alex Routi, Dean Routi, Jamie Johnson, and Robby Carl; and his two great-grandchildren, Braelyn and Salara Richardson.

Known for his warmth, humor, and generosity, Jim never met a stranger. He delighted in socializing and entertaining, and will be fondly remembered for his famous annual Kite Party at his West Meadow Beach home. His spirit touched all who knew him, and his loss will be felt deeply.

A celebration of Jim's life will be held at a later date.