Andrew L. Teitelbaum

Andrew Lee Teitelbaum, 69, passed away peacefully in his sleep at his home.

Born in 1956 in the Bronx, New York City, Andrew grew up alongside his older brother Steven and younger sister Barbra. From a young age, he was introduced to baseball by his grandfather—a game he loved passionately and later shared with his son. A lifelong Yankees fan, Andrew carried his love of the sport into adulthood and inspired his son to become a college baseball player.

Always energetic and adventurous, Andrew had a zest for life. He cherished countless memories from his time at SUNY Buffalo and his years living in New York City. Professionally, he became one of the top-rated insurance brokers in New York State, eventually founding Andrew Brokerage in Queens, where he ran a successful business for more than 30 years.

In 1992, Andrew married Diane Teitelbaum after a blind date he had initially tried to cancel. Their first official date ended up at Peter Luger steakhouse, and together they built a loving family with their children, Vanessa and Austin. In the 1990s, the family moved to Westhampton, where Andrew devoted himself to his family, becoming the ultimate family man.

Andrew was also an avid fisherman, spending weekends on the water and generously sharing his catches with neighbors. He would constantly bring any and all family members on the boat for a trip. Anyone who met Andy quickly recognized his warmth, generosity, humor, and one-of-a-kind spirit. People knew that if they needed help, they could turn to Andy.

He is survived by his wife, Diane Teitelbaum; daughter, Vanessa Teitelbaum; son, Austin Teitelbaum; and grandchildren Joshua, Victor, and Aliyah Soler, who will carry forward his lessons and make him proud as he watches from above.

Please Consider making a donation in Lieu of flowers to NY Cancer Society