Johnathan Jay Otto

Johnathan Jay "Jay Bird" Otto, 35, of Milwaukee, passed away unexpectedly on March 12, 2026.

Born September 12, 1990, in Milwaukee to Tracy Otto and Richard Rauch, Jay was raised with love by Tracy Otto, Sammie Broyld, and Jennifer Broyld. Known for his big heart, infectious smile, and loyal spirit, Jay lived life with passion and always showed up for the people he cared about.

Jay was a man of many skills and trades. He made a career as a tow truck driver and took great pride in helping others. Jay loved traveling for work, fishing, cheering on the Milwaukee Bucks, and spending time with his pitbull. Above all, he cherished time with his family and friends.

Jay is survived by his children, Johnathan Jr. and Jayla Otto; his parents, Sammie Broyld and Tracy Otto; his stepmother, Jennifer Broyld; and his siblings, Izabella, Austin, Cody, Layna, Katelyn, Dennis, Aidan, Aubree and Ava, along with many extended family members and friends.

Jay is preceded in death by his grandparents Teresa Rauch, Mary Randolph, William and Sharon Otto.

A Celebration of Life will be held on March 19th at Hartson Funeral Home in Hales Corner.

Jay lived life to the fullest, with a fierce spirit and generous heart. While his absence leaves a deep void, the love, laughter, and memories he gave will live on forever in the hearts of those who were fortunate enough to know him.