Cary J. Collins

1947 - 2025

Cary J. Collins

Oct 23, 1947 - Dec 26, 2025

Cary J. Collins was described countless ways throughout his nearly fifty years practicing law, "a lion among lawyers," "a terrific mentor," and a "&#%" by his adversaries, but all would agree he was a colorful character.

Born in Gary, Indiana on October 23, 1947, Cary was the oldest of six children and never let anyone forget it. His early years were spent at Holy Angels Grade School where he established life-long friendships.

Cary was always motivated. At ten years old, he became a paperboy for the Post Tribune. When he saved enough money, before he was old enough to drive, he bought his first car, "Peach Fuzz." With "wheels," he could deliver pizzas. Cary soon realized in a town like Gary, the only tips he would make were leftover pizzas, so he coerced his cousin Doug Fleming to refer him for his first "real" job. During the day he went to high school and worked nights and weekends selling women's shoes at Lyttons. After graduating from Horace Mann in 1965, Cary spent one year at the Merchant Marine Academy in Kings Point, New York. Deciding it would take him too long to reach the top of the chain of command, he returned to Northwest Indiana, achieving a business degree at Indiana University Northwest while working full time at Midwest Steel. For a short time, he worked at Florsheim Shoes corporate, but when he began law school at John Marshall, he joined the Bursar's Office at the University of Illinois Circle Campus.

In 1975, while still in law school, he met the love of his life, Sue O'Drobinak, on the slopes of a ski resort in Colorado. He knew immediately he had found the person who understood him best and would be his emotional rock and support for half a century.

Cary's first job out of law school was at The Hill Firm in Chicago, but again, if Cary wasn't in charge, something would have to change. So, after a short foray with another law office in downtown Chicago, he opened The Law Offices of Cary J. Collins in Hoffman Estates.

While serving as a village trustee, Cary assumed many roles in Hoffman Estates including the Parks and Recreation Board and Police and Fire Commission. When his mentor Mayor Mike O'Malley died, he briefly considered running for mayor but instead served as deputy mayor so he could spend more time practicing law.

Throughout his career, he ran for a few other political offices, but his outspoken personality was not conducive in getting him elected. This character trait enhanced his admiration for our current president.

Although Cary had a diverse law practice, his passion was assisting and advising police officers and firefighters. He established the Illinois Public Pension Advisory Committee to educate pension board trustees on their responsibilities. Cary spent countless volunteer hours explaining the complexities of pension law and helping first responders understand their rights and responsibilities.

For nearly forty years, Cary's and Sue's "Xanadu" was their home on North Twin Lake in Phelps, WI. Once Sue convinced Cary to move "up north" full time, he never looked back-relishing boating, fishing, and an idyllic laid-back lifestyle. He especially enjoyed his role as "the lawyer" who offered free legal advice to friends and acquaintances around Phelps.

In addition to Cary's devoted wife, Sue, who passed away in November, he was preceded in death by brothers, Tom Collins and Ted (Palika) Collins; as well as his parents, Betty and Richard Collins; nephew, Alex Collins; brothers-in-law, Warren Freiberg and Tom O'Drobinak; mother-in-law, Bertha O'Drobinak; cousin, Air Force Colonel Mike Collins; and cherished dogs, Shadow, Pepper, Sparkey, and Lady.

Cary also leaves behind his beloved dogs, Boots and Daisy and close friend, Mickey Walker of Elgin, IL. Cary is survived by siblings, Tim (Alisa) Collins of Genessee, CO, Cathy Collins of Montezuma, IN, and Libby Collins (Tony) Ryan of Elm Grove, WI. Other survivors include cousins, Cathleen and Tom Burrell, Peggy Totin, Jeff (Mary) Collins, Casey Collins, Margy (Bob) Cogswell, and numerous nieces and nephews including Marilyn Collins of Denver, CO, Robert Collins of Boulder, CO, Eric Collins of Chicago, Sean (Casie) Collins of Wisconsin, and Warren Christopher (Tara) Freiberg of Lowell, Indiana.

Cary was a member of St. Mary's Parish in Phelps, WI. He was proud of his NRA membership and although he had moved to Wisconsin, was still a member of the Knights of Columbus in Elgin, IL.

A Mass of Christian Burial was held at St. Mary's Parish in Phelps, WI, on Friday, January 2, 2026. A visitation in Northwest Indiana will be held on Wednesday, January 7, 2026, from 10 a.m. until the time of the funeral service at 11 a.m. at Burns Funeral Home & Crematory, 10101 Broadway, Crown Point, IN. Interment at St. John/St. Joseph Cemetery in Hammond, IN. www.burnsfuneral.com.