May God bless you and your...
Billy I never you but I wish I very much did and let me tell you that heaven needed an angel and now they got now and billy may your heart and soul live on forever!!!!!!!!!!!!
JOE BRUNO
October 08, 2025 | Other


Staten Island, New York
Billy O'Toole, 48 'Everywhere he went was a party' Billy was larger than life. Always fun to be around and made everyone he met feel like they were family. Born in Park Slope, Brooklyn, NY on August 30, 1970 to Barbara O'Toole and William Sheehan. He was a union carpenter by trade but the last...
Read MoreBilly I never you but I wish I very much did and let me tell you that heaven needed an angel and now they got now and billy may your heart and soul live on forever!!!!!!!!!!!!
JOE BRUNO
October 08, 2025 | Other

Just want to let billy children know I grew up with his dad on fourth street he was a very kind person with a heart of gold very respectful also always helped my nanny billy was funny some sense of humor he is in gods hands now a beautiful angel he resting peacefully and how the loved showed for his family you will forever be missed bj that´s what´s he´s friends called him on 7 ave we love you always
Kim
July 15, 2021 | Friend
I´m surprised I never met him or I did it´s been awhile I lived in park slope 4 st between 7 and 8 ave.. rip billy
Geo
June 29, 2021 | Other
Much respect and rest easy long live the Irish god bless you
Jay
June 18, 2021 | Friend
I never met Mr. O'Toole but enjoyed him on the reality show Mafia Families. He seemed like a nice guy. I was sad to hear of his passing. Daily prayers to his family and friends. Earth hath no sorrow that Heaven can not Heal.
Doreen Tanner
May 01, 2021
Rip Billy Im so sorry to you all for your loss, I lost my dad at 9 and It was the worst pain ever. It crushed me. Billy he was so funny and bright and loyal on the show and honestly my favorite! Please know hes at rest n peace ❤ my condolences to Jess and the kids. Gone but never forgotten..
sammy
June 23, 2020 | Philly Pa | Acquaintance
RIP Billy... U touched my heart ❤ and you will be missed very much!
TINA KOZUHOWSKI
May 18, 2020 | Friend
Our family are fans of the MTV reality TV hit series called, "Families Of The Mafia". My wife, our son, and I tuned in to view the program every week, and had never missed an episode. We enjoyed watching the show, very much. Unfortunately, on July 14th, 2019 a very special person who was a cast member and instrumental in helping to create the successful reality TV series had passed away. Billy O'Toole was suddenly and unexpectedly taken away from his loving family members, his dear friends,...
Brian Eardley
May 16, 2020 | New City, NY | Acquaintance
I am so sorry For your loss my love and prayers goes out to his family I watched the show faithfully and loved everything about Billy! He will be missed very much
Shirley
May 14, 2020 | Friend