Menu
Search by Name
Search by Name
FUNERAL HOME
Jay Prensky Obituary
Jay Gary Prensky
Beloved husband, father, son, brother, friend and physician passed away on December 23, 2019. He was 66 years old. Jay was known for his enthusiasm and excellence in everything he did. He received his medical degree from the University of Maryland School of Medicine, completed his medical residency at University of Wisconsin-Madison and his medical fellowship at Duke University. Jay spent the bulk of his career as a partner at Pennsylvania Retina Specialists in Camp Hill, PA. He was well known by his patients, neighbors and business partners as a compassionate and dedicated friend, physician and human being. He was an avid cyclist, pedaling thousands of miles each year even after suffering significant injuries. He is survived by his wife, Colleen (Harpt) of Camp Hill, PA, his son, Colin and daughter Mia, both of Pittsburgh, PA, parents, Bernard (Buddy) and Rhona of Chevy Chase, MD, brother, David of Arlington, VA, and sister, Gail of Washington, DC. Services will be held Sunday, December 29 at 10 a.m. at Ohr Kodesh Synagogue in Chevy Chase, MD. Contributions can be made in memory of Jay may be given to the Jay Prensky, MD Memorial Fund: (https://judischekulturbund.wedid.it/campaigns/7147)
To plant trees in memory, please visit the Sympathy Store.
Memories and Condolences
for Jay Prensky
Julia
December 21, 2022
I think of you more times than you could imagine. Miss you so much
Kristen B
April 1, 2020
Donna Rentzel
February 26, 2020
PA Retina will never be the same. Dr. P took care of my eye for me for the last several years. I enjoyed my visits with him (even when I needed the dreaded injection). I always lectured him about the bicycle riding and cautioned him. I will miss him terribly. He is gone too soon!!!
Mark Bachleda
January 26, 2020
Dr.Prensky was my wife's doctor and I have no doubt he saved what's left of her eyesight from complications with diabetes. My wife, Maggie and I were deeply saddened to hear of the doctor's passing and we both are very grateful for what he was able to do to save her eyesight.
Our deepest sympathies go out to the family and friends of Dr. Prensky.
Ben Machamer
January 24, 2020
I lost one of my hero's .
This man saved my vision 32 years ago. Jay did my diabetic retinopathy surgery to both of my retinas. You may think no big deal. That's what a retina surgeon does The reason I make such a big deal of it is in those 32 years I have not needed one touch up which is very unusual.
He did such a job that during many eye exams other doctors would sit back and ask with astonishment. who did your retina work?
I would tease Dr Prensky that he must have signed his initials back there.
I actually looked forward to my visits there and will miss our bantering and joking back and forth.
I can only assume that all of his patients had the same relationship. He was just that kind of guy.
Peddle on Doc..... God speed
Marie Clover Family
January 23, 2020
Oh how deeply saddened to hear about Dr Prensky. He was such a special and caring person. My parents had been long time patients of his and they always enjoyed seeing what bow tie he was wearing that day. He also loved the treats mom made sure to bring and he complemented on how nice it was for her to think of him. He will be truly missed by all of us. Prayers for his family at this time of loss.
Regina Munchel
January 23, 2020
How deeply saddened I am to hear of Dr. Prensky's passing. I was truly looking forward to and hoping for his return to the office. I'd pray often for him over the past year or so. My sincere condolences and sympathy to his family, co-workers and staff at both the York and Camp Hill offices where I've been a patient for the past 3 1/2 years. He always seemed in high gear when he was there.
But he made time for me. I was first scheduled for an emergency visit as the Opthalmologist thought I'd had a detached retina and a torn iris. I will never forget this first visit. It ended up that I had neither, but there were other issues that oh so perplexed him. I was a bit scared of him at first, but I was not understanding his determination or passion. I think I was there for an hour or two. But because of his doggedness to get to the truth, there were other issues that were brought to light. He even took the time to have a long consultation with another specialist on my behalf because of these.
I grew to really appreciate, like, and trust Dr. Prensky. I've missed seeing him on a regular basis. I will also never forget, in one of our latter appts, where he turned around, leaning back and looking at me fatherly like, said If you have ANY problems, call me. I think my mother had just passed away.
He was compassionate and patient. (Oh I hated those shots!!!)
I will truly truly miss him.
Melissa Howard
January 23, 2020
Our family was very saddened to learn of Dr. Prensky's passing. We've loved having him as a neighbor. He has been such a wonderful, motivating presence to stay active and enjoy the outdoors. Seeing him cycling or running in our neighborhood or out tending his yard was always a joy. He consistently had thoughtfulness and enthusiasm to share each time we saw him. Our block will not be the same without him.
Jim Paul
January 22, 2020
Just learned and very saddened ... Dr. Prensky initially validated my ocular issues, but was always optimistic about outcomes. I valued his care, guidance, and desk side manners - always positive, upbeat. Will miss my appointments with him and the great care that he provided ... my condolences to the family.
Noel Marks
January 19, 2020
Dr. Prensky was a wonderful caring Retina Specialist who treated my condition for 3 years. He was always extremely upbeat and energetic with an engaging smile and spirit. I and countless other patients will miss his dedication and service. Condolences to his family.
Frank Barry
January 16, 2020
While I did not know Jay very well I always thought the best of him. I saw him as a thoughtful son and father, a good man and always a gentleman. Buddy and Rhonda please know that you have my sincere sympathy and that you and your family are in my thoughts and prayers. Im so sorry.
DR JEFFREY KIRCHNER
January 14, 2020
I HAD THE GOOD PLEASURE OF MEETING JAY AND HIS FATHER AROUND 2001 WHEN WE WERE FLYING FROM HARRISBURG TO RUN THE BOSTON MARATHON YEARS AGO - WE STAYED IN TOUCH / I HAVE KIND MOTIVATING MEMORIES OF HIM. VERY YOUNG FROM MY VANTAGE POINT.
Andy and Agi Sternberg
January 11, 2020
Dear Buddy and Rhona - we just heard about your son. Please accept our sincerest condolences. NO words can ease the pain. Agi and Andy
Emilie Tierney
January 8, 2020
Prensky Family:
We are so sad knowing that Jay is no longer sharing this universe with us. He was a GREAT Physician and cycling friend. May Jay's light shine through all of us who knew him.
Hoping that memories of better days are healing.
With love and peace.....Emilie Tierney and Murray Sperling. Camp Hill
Tim Funk
January 7, 2020
So sorry to hear of Dr. Prensky's passing. As a long time patient it was always a joy to see him not only for his professional expertise but for his upbeat personality, social wit and positive outlook. His passion for life, energy and concern for the environment was an inspiration to me. God bless him for his spirit that touched everyone in his presence. He deserved a much longer life on this planet. Tim Funk
January 6, 2020
I was so sad to hear of Jay's passing. I will miss him so very much. I really enjoyed our conversations. He was such a kind, nice person and an excellent physician. Please send my condolences to his family.
John O. Barton, M.D.
Deborah Sipe
December 31, 2019
Dr. Prensky will be missed very much. He was not only my doctor but my 13 year old granddaughter's as well. He was a skilled physician and eye surgeon but also a kind caring human being. My sympathy to the Prensky family, the staff that worked with him, and the community who have lost an extraordinary human being.
Bob Kuntz
December 31, 2019
Dear Prensky Family: Words can't express the sincere sympathy and condolences I extend to all of you at this very sad time. Your Husband, Dad, Doctor and Friend was one of the best people I have ever met in my life. As everyone knows he was a renown Retina Specialist and Doctor, but most of all a true friend and comforter to all his patients and friends. It's a frightening time in ones life when your vision is in serious jeopardy, but God placed a true Angel here among us to help us through such difficult times. Dr. Jay was just an incredible, accomplished, polished and down to earth human being and friend. The world has truly lost one of its best people. Dr. Jay, you will be missed incredibly by all of us who had the sincere pleasure of being both your patient and friend. I pray you keep keen watch over your family and all of us from above. May you rest in heavenly peace which you so richly deserve. God Bless and may He watch over your beautiful family.
December 30, 2019
I was very saddened to hear of the loss of Jay Prensky, a colleague and friend. We always had a jovial greeting when meeting each other during our patient care duties at Holy Spirit Hospital. My sincere condolences to his family and many friends.
Ronald M. Grossman, M.D.
Atlanta Georgia
Lori Mosley
December 30, 2019
Sending my condolences to the family and friends of Dr. Prensky. He was such a wonderful person and it's been a blessing to get to know Dr.Prensky as my eye specialists. Sorry to learn of his passing. He will be truly missed
Patrick Basom
December 30, 2019
Dr. Prensky was a great man! A true Mensch. God bless his soul! He was a customer of mine for a long time many years ago at Jos A Bank where he would purchase his trademark bow ties. We frequently would trade good wishes back and forth for his Jewish holidays and my Christian holidays. He was always a joy to see and chat with, even if it was for the short time at the office. Thankfully, I lived around the block from him and was fortunate to interact with him on a personal level too. Especially during National Night Out held at Willow Park, where he lived. I am forever grateful for the superior and delicate care that he gave me with my Retinopathy. Camp Hill and the world will miss his genuine and humorous persona and the healing touch that he gave to so many of us.
December 29, 2019
Dr. Prensky touched every patient's heart.
He will be missed by all the people came across in medicine field, social contacts or cycling enthusiasts. RIP Dr. Prensky.
Alan Gallagher
December 29, 2019
My sincere sympathies to the Prensky family. Dr. Prensky was one of my most favorite clients. He was always a pleasure to work with and I consider it a privilege that he entrusted me to be his insurance agent.
Alan W. Gallagher, Lemoyne
December 29, 2019
I am so sad to hear of Jay's passing. My thoughts go out to Collen, Colin and Mia! I will always remember his intense love of life! He always made me feel better after talking to him.
Maryellen Harner
Thelma Shumway
December 29, 2019
My deepest sympathy to the Prensky family. He had been my retina doctor and was very compassionate and instilled confidence. I'm grateful to have met him.
Eric Miller
December 29, 2019
Thank you, you will be missed! I think God that he gave you the know how I've had to perform and carry out retina surgeries. Without you and the hands of God I would not be able to see. Thank you for being my doctor and a friend for my entire life. Because, that's how long I have known you 36 years. Grace and peace to your family
Beverly Mullen
December 29, 2019
Dr. Prensky was my 97 year old mother's eye doctor for several years. He helped her with her macular degeneration with kindness and compassion. We are indeed saddened by the news of his passing. Our condolences to his family and friends. May he rest in peace.
Michael Curran-Hays
December 29, 2019
We are so sad to learn of Jay's passing. He was a friend, a running buddy and a doctor to us. We will miss him. Our hearts go out to Colleen, Colin and Mia.
Michael and Peggy Curran-Hays
PRS Holiday Party 2018
Danielle Crumlich
December 29, 2019
Elizabeth Swartz
December 29, 2019
Dr Prensky was my eye surgeon since 1995 when I had a detached retina. He was a wonderful doctor, always pleasant and loved seeing him with his bow ties.
Deepest sympathy to his family & work family. He will be missed!
Rick Blood
December 29, 2019
May Jay rest in peace. Whenever I would see Jay, he was always interested in how I was doing. A caring individual that I got to know through the Camp Hill running group. My prayers and condolences to out to his many friends and family.
December 28, 2019
He was my husband's doctor for many years and saved some sight in his eye for which we are eternally grateful. Such a sad time for his family and we send our sympathy and prayers. John and Sandy Sellers
December 28, 2019
He lived his life to help others. He felt it was a privilege to be a doctor. Participating in research trials for new treatments for eye diseases was a passion and I was lucky enough to closely share that with him. Our patients have lost a friend, not their doctor.
PHYLLIS LEVENGOOD
December 28, 2019
Deepest sympathy to the Prensky family. I was a patient of Dr Prensky for many years. He was always upbeat,friendly, and made my day better just by his presence. He would always have a kind word and a laugh for me. I will miss him as well as countless other patients and friends. Rest in Peace Dr. Prensky. Phyllis Levengood
Amy Penner
December 28, 2019
There are no words to describe how fantastic Dr. Prensky was as my doctor nor are there words to describe the devastation and loss his passing leaves. He was simply the most positive and energetic man I have ever met and my heart aches that he is gone from this world. Please know that his patients cared for him and are grieving for your family. Sincerely, Amy Penner
Sandeep Kakaria
December 28, 2019
Jay was an excellent physician and a kind man. I will remember him as a smiling, positive person who helped thousands of patients and many doctors in our community.
Melissia Nassar
December 27, 2019
Amazing Surgeon!! Had the pleasure of working with at WSSC!!!
Brice Arndt
December 27, 2019
Prayers to all. Jay was an exceptional physician and athletic competitor.
N. S.
December 27, 2019
My deepest sympathy to the family of Jay Gary Prensky. May you be comforted In knowing that our Heavenly Father cares for you. He will give you strength and courage to cope with your grief. Psalm 94:17-19
Julianne Baltozer
December 27, 2019
I am deeply sorry for your loss. I am also a cyclist and would often see Jay at the JCC working on his swimming. He was a wonderful man who will be missed immensely. My prayers to the family.
3 of the best Retina surgeons
Kristen ❤
December 27, 2019
Happy Halloween
Kristen ❤
December 27, 2019
Packers Fans
Kristen ❤
December 27, 2019
Halloween Fun
Kristen ❤
December 27, 2019
Football Fun at work
Kristen ❤
December 27, 2019
Texas trip with Jay 2017
hannah eckstein-gowans
December 27, 2019
December 27, 2019
I worked with Dr. Prensky for 11 years and knew him to be a loving, caring person who was admired my his coworkers as well as his patients. He always had a warm smile a great laugh and a strong hand when you needed one. I am a better person for knowing him and I am very sorry for his loss. Rest in Peace Dr. Prensky.
Riding with Jay in Texas 2017
hannah eckstein-gowans
December 27, 2019
Jay will be sorely missed. Such a great guy and so fun to ride with. RIP Jay. Peace to all
Chris Vitt
December 27, 2019
Jay will be greatly missed by his many cycling Friends in Central PA, he was a favorite member of our Group rides. I was lucky to be Jay's roommate in February 2107 on a cycling trip to Texas. We got along great and always enjoyed talking about the day's ride and the interesting sights along the way. Jay was always up for a challenge and approached it with energy, he was always upbeat and positive. I'll miss Jay and hope that he is at Peace. I wish comfort and strength for his Family, my sincerest condolences for the loss of a good man, husband, father, and son.
Ed and Lori Knittel
December 27, 2019
Your presence here in the borough will be missed. Prayers for peace, relief from pain, and comfort for family and friends.
Showing 1 - 51 of 51 results
Make a Donation
in Jay Prensky's name
Memorial Events
for Jay Prensky
Funeral services provided by:
Hines-Rinaldi Funeral Home - Silver Spring11800 New Hampshire Ave, Silver Spring, MD 20904
How to support Jay's loved ones
Honor a beloved veteran with a special tribute of ‘Taps’ at the National WWI Memorial in Washington, D.C.
The nightly ceremony in Washington, D.C. will be dedicated in honor of your loved one on the day of your choosing.
Read more
Should I Send Sympathy Flowers?
What kind of arrangement is appropriate, where should you send it, and when should you send an alternative?
Read more
What Should I Write in a Sympathy Card?
We'll help you find the right words to comfort your family member or loved one during this difficult time.
Read moreResources to help you cope with loss
Estate Settlement Guide
If you’re in charge of handling the affairs for a recently deceased loved one, this guide offers a helpful checklist.
Read more
Obituaries, grief & privacy: Legacy’s news editor on NPR podcast
Legacy's Linnea Crowther discusses how families talk about causes of death in the obituaries they write.
Read more
The Five Stages of Grief
They're not a map to follow, but simply a description of what people commonly feel.
Read moreWays to honor Jay Prensky's life and legacy
Obituary Examples
You may find these well-written obituary examples helpful as you write about your own family.
Read more
Obituary Templates – Customizable Examples and Samples
These free blank templates make writing an obituary faster and easier.
Read more
How Do I Write a Eulogy?
Some basic help and starters when you have to write a tribute to someone you love.
Read more
