Evelyn Realta O'Neil

Evelyn O'Neil passed away peacefully on March 15, 2026, at the age of 94. Born on July 26, 1931, in the town of Clay Banks, Wisconsin, Evelyn was the daughter of Herman and Minnie Meister. Her life was a testament to love, service, and commitment to her family and community.

Evelyn spent her early years in Sturgeon Bay, where she cultivated a love for learning and teaching. After graduating from Normal School in 1951, she pursued her passion for education, eventually earning a Master's Degree in Reading in 1973. Evelyn began her teaching career in Sugar Bush before dedicating many years to the Neenah public schools, where she taught elementary level until her retirement in 1987.

On August 9, 1958, Evelyn married the love of her life, Vernon O'Neil. During their marriage of nearly 51 years, they raised three children: Cindy Fahrenkrug, Linda (Bruce) Oines, and Paddy (Teresa) O'Neil, who were the pride and joy of Evelyn's life.

Evelyn's love extended beyond her immediate family. She was the proud grandmother of Brendan and Ryan Fahrenkrug, and great-grandmother to three girls. Evelyn's family was her greatest treasure, and she was known for creating a warm and welcoming home where everyone felt cherished and loved.

Evelyn's sister, Angelus (Joseph) Robinson's family was important to her, as well: Dennis (Jane) Robinson (deceased), James Robinson (deceased), Patsy Robinson, Sharon Robinson (deceased), Karen (Tom) Leist, Laurie Robinson, John Robinson, Scott (Sussie) Robinson, and Tina Robinson (deceased).

A dedicated member of her church and community, Evelyn's faith was a guiding light throughout her life. She was an active participant in the Birchwood United Methodist Church and lately the West Valley Christian Fellowship in Arizona. She made dear friends through her work with the church. Her voice graced the Fox Valley Chorus and the Rice Lake Chorus of Sweet Adelines, where she shared her love of music with many.

Evelyn was a creative soul, finding joy in sewing and quilting, knitting, and cross-stitch. Her home was a testament to her artistic talents, especially during the Christmas season, when her decorations turned her space into a winter wonderland, delighting all who visited.

Evelyn was preceded in death by her parents, Herman and Minnie Meister; her sister, Angelus Robinson; her beloved husband, Vernon O'Neil; and her son-in-law, David Fahrenkrug. She leaves behind a legacy of love and kindness that will be carried forward by her children, grandchildren, great-grandchildren, and all who had the privilege of knowing her.

A service to celebrate Evelyn's remarkable life will be held on Saturday, May 16, 2026, at 11:00 a.m. at Birchwood United Methodist Church, located at 103 E Balsam Ave, Birchwood, WI 54817. Family and friends are invited to gather in remembrance and to honor a woman who touched so many with her warmth and grace.