Legacy Logo
Andrew James Shay

Andrew James Shay

1964 - 2025

Buy Gifts

Memorialized in partnership with Simplicity Funeral & Cremation Care - Indianapolis

Read Andrew's Obituary

Quotation Mark

Andrew James Shay Beloved Husband, Father, Son, and Grandfather Indianapolis, Indiana Andrew James Shay, of Indianapolis, passed away on August 20, 2025. A man of charisma, quick wit, and boundless curiosity, Andy lived his life with a smile for everyone and never met a stranger. Born to Stephen F....

Read the full obituary on our trusted partner sites below.

https://cache.legacy.net/globalcontent/funeralhomelogos/portallogo/31355portallogo.png

Other Ways to Support the Family

Missing or inaccurate information?

We want to honor your loved one’s memory with accuracy and care.

Contact customer support