Timothy "Tim" Schlageter

Timothy "Tim" Schlageter obituary, Willoughby, OH

Timothy "Tim" Schlageter

Timothy Schlageter Obituary

Obituary published on Legacy.com by McMahon - Coyne - Vitantonio Funeral Home - Mentor on Nov. 18, 2025.

Publish in a newspaper

Timothy "Tim" Schlageter ObituaryThough Timothy Schlageter has left this world, the light he gave it will never fade. Tim, 65, of Mentor-on-the-Lake, passed away on August 25 after a life lived with hard work, conviction, and love.
Tim was preceded in death by his parents, Roy and Hazel Schlageter, and his brothers, Benny Knotts and Randall Schlageter. He is survived by his loving companion Christine Trusty; his son, James Schlageter; his daughters, Amy (Byron) Floyd and Shannon (Eric) Starkey; his grandchildren, Brennen "Tim" Mansell, Byron (Carmen) Floyd, Shealyn Herda, and McKayla Herda; his siblings, Russ Knotts, Becky (Jay) Caswell, Kathy Kocevar, Patrick Schlageter, and Melanie (Jeff) Fultz; and his beloved nieces and nephews.
Tim lived life his way. For over 40 years, he owned and operated Tim's Auto Body, beginning with just $2,500 and a dream. What he built was more than a business, he didn't just fix cars; he helped restore people. Whether someone was down on their luck, fighting addiction, or simply in need of a chance, Tim was there. He believed in second chances, and he had a way of seeing the good in others even when they couldn't see it in themselves.
Tim was also a builder of more than just cars. From his first garage in his parents' backyard, to remodeling homes, to completing the dream building he had worked toward all his life, his hands and his heart were always at work.
He gave new life to what others cast aside, from scrap metal to souls in need of hope. No matter the circumstance, if you truly needed him, he was there without hesitation.
Tim will be remembered for his honesty, his strength, and his beautiful soul. He leaves behind not only the family who adored him, but also countless lives he touched along the way. His love for his family, friends, and God was fierce and steady.
Hug the Big House in the Sky, Tim. You were a true professional at life.
A Celebration of Tim will be held during calling hours on Monday, September 1, from 1–6 pm at McMahon-Coyne-Vitantonio Funeral Home, 6330 Center St., Mentor, OH. A Catholic Service will be held Tuesday, September 2, at 1 pm at St. Bede the Venerable Catholic Church, 9114 Lakeshore Blvd., Mentor, OH, followed by burial at Mentor Cemetery. All who knew Tim - family, friends, colleagues, and the many people whose lives he touched - are welcome to join us in honoring the eclectic man he was.
To plant a beautiful memorial tree in memory of Timothy, please visit our .
Though Timothy Schlageter has left this world, the light he gave it will never fade. Tim, 65, of Mentor-on-the-Lake, passed away on August 25 after a life lived with hard work, conviction, and love.
Tim was preceded in death by his parents, Roy and Hazel Schlageter, and his brothers, Benny Knotts and Randall Schlageter. He is su

To plant trees in memory, please visit the Sympathy Store.

McMahon - Coyne - Vitantonio Funeral Home - Mentor

6330 Center Street (Route 615, north of Route 2), Mentor, OH 44060

Make a Donation
in Timothy Schlageter's name

How to support Timothy's loved ones
Attending a Funeral: What to Know

You have funeral questions, we have answers.

Read more
Should I Send Sympathy Flowers?

What kind of arrangement is appropriate, where should you send it, and when should you send an alternative?

Read more
What Should I Write in a Sympathy Card?

We'll help you find the right words to comfort your family member or loved one during this difficult time.

Read more
Poems of Mourning and Comfort

The best poems for funerals, memorial services., and cards.

Read more
Resources to help you cope with loss
How to Cope With Grief

Information and advice to help you cope with the death of someone important to you.

Read more
Estate Settlement Guide

If you’re in charge of handling the affairs for a recently deceased loved one, this guide offers a helpful checklist.

Read more
How to Write an Obituary

Need help writing an obituary? Here's a step-by-step guide...

Read more
Obituaries, grief & privacy: Legacy’s news editor on NPR podcast

Legacy's Linnea Crowther discusses how families talk about causes of death in the obituaries they write.

Read more
Ways to honor Timothy Schlageter's life and legacy
Obituary Examples

You may find these well-written obituary examples helpful as you write about your own family.

Read more
How to Write an Obituary

Need help writing an obituary? Here's a step-by-step guide...

Read more
Obituary Templates – Customizable Examples and Samples

These free blank templates make writing an obituary faster and easier.

Read more
How Do I Write a Eulogy?

Some basic help and starters when you have to write a tribute to someone you love.

Read more

Sign Timothy Schlageter's Guest Book

Not sure what to say?