Obituary
Guest Book
Publish in a newspaper
To plant trees in memory, please visit the Sympathy Store.
Vincent L. Maola
January 24, 2025
I was John´s first arranging teacher. Having gone to E. Liverpool H. S., I knew John. He was four years behind me; I graduated in 1952. After my first year in college (Ohio Wesleyan), I came home & got a call from John. He knew that I was a music major & he had questions about arranging for Band. I would sit with him explaining, as best I could, range of instruments, keys of the instruments etc. He wanted to know everything that I could tell him about arranging. I was a beginner & did the best I could to fill him in on the capabilities of the various instruments. The first song we worked on was: "Hernandos Hideaway"...I think from the musical: "Pajama Game".
I got to work with John several times over the years as we both went back to E. Liverpool for reunions...I conducted the alumni band & John had fun playing in the percussion section. I am so sorry to hear of his passing even though I knew there were health issues. God Bless Him & "Hang on Sloopy".
Patrick O'Flaherty
August 10, 2024
John was at 34-36 Chittenden across from the Law Library in 1956 and believe he was playing with the Al Wasline (sp) Band at the time. Recall him coming in around 2-3 am, brushing his teeth in our bathroom and singing songs he must played that evening. He did show me things on my guitar at the time and recall Momma Dion who ran the house taking care of him when he was sick. Left there in Fall Qtr of 1957 and only saw him again at the pre-game shows at St. John. What a life he had!!!
Douglas H. Stein
April 8, 2024
Just heard the sad news as expressed so eloquently by an alumnus of TBDBITL. I wouldn´t have wanted to hear it from anyone else quite frankly, because I know how much TBDBITL alumni appreciated and adored John. I have always gone to the liner notes and looked for John´s name and I always got a thrill to see the arrangement was by the great John Tagenhorst. His music and arrangements will live on for generations to come!
Gail james
April 7, 2024
So very sorry to hear of John´s passing. I was just thirteen and was a neighbor of he and Sue. I babysat the kids; Timmy and Michelle. Changing her diapers and watching the local TV show where John played the drums. Timmy was so excited...saying "that´s Daddy!" Even though I was just a young teenager, he always spoke to me as an adult and I just loved that! AND he had the best music albums that I listened to all day. May he rest in peace and may your memories be a blessing. Kindly, Gail (Gonser) James
Send flowers
Consider sending flowers.
Add photos
Share their life with photo memories.
Plant trees
Honor them by planting trees in their memory.
Follow this page
Get email updates whenever changes are made.
Donate in Memory
Make a donation in memory of your loved one.
Share this page
Invite other friends and family to visit the page.
Ed Duling
April 6, 2024
I knew John in a way that no one else has mentioned. I knew him mainly as the percussion instructor at Capital university in the mid-70s when I was a student there. I was a music education major, he was the instructor for percussion methods classes. I think all of us enjoyed having him for that class and I believe the percussion majors also learned much from him in their lessons. Ed Duling
Bill Highfield
April 6, 2024
Bill Highfield
Our prayers go out to the Tatgenhorst family. I was a student of John at Van's in Columbus Ohio until I graduated from high school in 1965. I joined the Marine Corp and was sent to Japan. I got lucky and ended up playing in the Marine Corp Drum and Bugle Corp Japan for over 2 years. It was because of all the preparation John walked us through that I was able to audition. I passed the audition and played snare drum for the remainder of my tour. John was my musical mentor I have always looked up to. I do have a memory of John and Gene Kruppa giving us a treat at a recital for his students. John was giving the set his all and he looked over to Kruppa who was mimicking him but with just one hand. John then let Gene tell his story. John was a wonderful man, motivator, instructor and someone many of us looked up to as the best in the business. You will be missed.
Bill Kisinger
April 6, 2024
So sorry. Many fond memories with John during his association with Purdue Bands. A delightful gentleman!
Bill and Susan Kisinger
Joe Theis
April 5, 2024
John was my uncle who gave me the courage and inspiration to play the drums and perform in various cover bands throughout my life. Words can not exspress the sadness that i feel right now. He will forever always be in my heart.
Your nephew, Joseph E, Theis
Dorene Moore
April 5, 2024
Prayers to the Tatgenhorst Family. As an Ohio State fan & mom to a TBDBITL member, John´s legacy will live on in his music. May you rest in peace.
John Minnich
April 4, 2024
John Tatgenhorst was my drum set teacher in high school, then my marimba teacher as I prepared to attend Capital University. He was my mentor and instructor through my 4 years at Capital while I earned my Bachelor of Music Ed degree. He got me started in the music business and his drumming style and teaching were what molded me into the professional drummer/percussionist I am today, and I am eternally grateful to him for that. RIP to a mentor and friend.
Brad McDavid
April 4, 2024
I was so honored that John was willing to share his incredible arranging talent with the Husky Band. The HMB family will forever be grateful.
Luke Toussaint
April 4, 2024
RIP John. I dont go to OSU but I am a huge fan of TBDBITL. You made Hang On Sloopy as much a part of gameday as Script Ohio and Carmen Ohio. OH-IO.
Jim Ferguson
April 4, 2024
My wife and John graduated in the same class in high school, and I played in the percussion section of the band with John. Several of us in the band were good friends and enjoyed meeting up again in the alumni band at East Liverpool reunions. John will be missed.
Michael Hatfield
April 3, 2024
John was my first drum teacher at Van's Music in Columbus, and was also instrumental in starting me on the vibraphone. I cleaned his studio in exchange for lessons, and enjoyed his teaching style and humor. He made a real difference in my musical life, and I am very thankful for that, and he's left a wonderful musical legacy at OSU that will go on for years.
David Patton
April 3, 2024
I had the pleasure of working with John on a number of projects including the musical packages for Columbus State Community College & the Ohio State Fair. I have some great memories related to those projects & was honored to be able to work with such a talented individual. David Patton, Columbus, OH
Jerry Lawson
April 3, 2024
I will always remember the playing of a new Tatgenhorst arrangement for the OSUMB. Little did we know when we played Hang On Sloopy for the first time that we were participating in the birth of a Buckeye Tradition, It is an unreplacable memory for me,
Joan McCready
April 3, 2024
My husband and I feel quite honored to have known John in his glory days at Ohio State. Not only did we work with him in conjunction with the OSUMB, but we helped him by copying music parts for him for other bands - at his home. When Matt got a job as junior high band director in East Liverpool, we met his mother at the polling place on election day! See you in the Horseshoe in the sky someday! Joan (Winger) and Matthew McCready
Deb Glett
April 3, 2024
I was in the ohio state marching band 1980 to 82. I had learned to play the horn at ohio state in order to try out for the band , switching from percussion. I Was much less experienced at reading music than many of my fellow band members, who have been doing this since they were in elementary school. Struggled every week to memorize our music and was always relieved when I saw this man's name at the top of the page. His arrangements were always straightforward, yet beautiful and such a joy to play. My condolences to his family and friends at this time.
Eric Aho
April 2, 2024
John was bigger than life in the eyes of many of us. He loved visitors, especially OSUMB alumni and especially 'current' members of the band. I think he secretly wished his college days at OSU had never ended... as he would light up when current members were in his midst at his home or when he was back on campus... he loved any and all stories. We all will meet again in the Heavenly Horseshoe and Stadium Band Room. John will be on snare and ready for the cadence to start rehearsal! O-H! John Tatgenhorst
Rose Angelica
April 2, 2024
I knew John at OSU in the 70´s and we stayed great friends! I loved spending time with him at Buckeye Football Games and talking about The Ohio Valley. He will be greatly missed and was a great talent. Deepest sympathy to Lisa and family.
Marty Jenkins
April 2, 2024
I got to meet John when I was an OSU band-obsessed middle schooler in Columbus. My best friend´s dad was in advertising and worked with John. Once when he had John over, my friend and I "entertained" him with a tuba and snare drum rendition of Sloopy. John was charming and gracious, and later gifted each of us a signed set of band parts for Sloopy.
Showing 1 - 21 of 21 results
282 E. Marquette Street PO Box 201, Berlin, WI 54923

The nightly ceremony in Washington, D.C. will be dedicated in honor of your loved one on the day of your choosing.
Read more
What kind of arrangement is appropriate, where should you send it, and when should you send an alternative?
Read more
We'll help you find the right words to comfort your family member or loved one during this difficult time.
Read more
Information and advice to help you cope with the death of someone important to you.
Read moreIf you’re in charge of handling the affairs for a recently deceased loved one, this guide offers a helpful checklist.
Read more
Legacy's Linnea Crowther discusses how families talk about causes of death in the obituaries they write.
Read more
You may find these well-written obituary examples helpful as you write about your own family.
Read more
These free blank templates make writing an obituary faster and easier.
Read more
Some basic help and starters when you have to write a tribute to someone you love.
Read more